Christina Aguilera and Eminem were engaged in one of the most legendary celebrity feuds of the early ’00s, but a viral fan theory suggests that their relationship could have gone very differently.

In fact, some fans think that the “Genie in a Bottle” diva and “Mockingbird” rapper might have wound up as an A-list couple.

After digging through some archival footage, fans were able to document what appears to be the exact moment where Christina and Eminem both went from publicly admitting to crushing on each other to Eminem lambasting the pop star across several of his songs.

Scroll through the slideshow to get a better understanding of Christina Aguilera and Eminem’s legendary feud, and where it all began…