Biniyam Shibre: Why Did Ex-Wife Bria Ditch Him to Raise Their Son Alone?

Ariela Weinberg and Biniyam Shibre made their 90 Day Fiance comeback with a splash.

While many of us were familiar with the The Other Way alums long before Ariela got blasted with red wine, there are still questions.

The specter of Bini’s ex has haunted his relationship with Ari since day one.

But why exactly did his ex-wife leave him to raise their child in America as a single mom?

Years ago, Biniyam Shibre met Bria when she was visiting Ethiopia.

Like Ariela, Bria was an American woman from an affluent family.

They hooked up, she ended up being pregnant … also like Ariela.

Biniyam has spoken repeatedly about his heartbreak over losing his family — Bria, but also his young son, Simon.

He has only shared a limited amount of information about why (from his side of things) Bria broke up with him.

Bini has said that he was “confused” by the split, but that’s not really an explanation.

Biniyam also admitted that Bria had accused him of cheating.

While she was certainly not the last to do so, Bini insisted that he was merely speaking to another woman, who was his friend.

Bini told her that he “didn’t do anything wrong,” but Bria ended up blocking him, raising her son alone in the United States.

It is heartbreaking to think of a family torn apart.

Breakups happen — even for married couples, even for couples with children.

But fans have wondered why Bini lost all access to his child, seemingly, and wondered if there is more to the story.

At the same time, it’s puzzling that Biniyam would apparently not effect any changes in his life and in his behavior as a partner.

To hear him tell it, Bria accused him of cheating, he denied it, and then she broke up with him.

That’s vague … but it also hasn’t seemed to be enough of a hint for Bini to act as a better partner to other women.

Biniyam’s ex-girlfriend, the one whose butt he sometimes plays like a drum set, also believed that he cheated when they dated.

Ariela confirmed this after having her own suspicions.

Even if Bini is somehow totally innocent of cheating in all three cases, he didn’t exactly do a lot to quash any “unfounded” suspicions.

Biniyam Shibre - I switched off my phone

A major issue for Ari and Biniyam on 90 Day Fiance: The Other Way Season 3 was Bini going unreachable, on purpose, for hours or days at a time.

It was already bad when Ari and baby Avi were there in Ethiopia, waiting for him at home but unable to reach him.

It was worse when they were in New Jersey, trying to reach him but unable to, while Bini turned their family home into a party house and music studio.

Some fans have wondered if Biniyam is playing some sort of long con with Ariela.

He ostensibly wants to be reunited with Simon, but cannot just go to the United States whenever he likes.

Impregnating an American tourist who comes from money with the plan of eventually marrying her and moving to the US would be a plan to get what he wants.

That said … it’s really difficult to see Biniyam as some sort of evil genius.

If his goal were to come to the United States all along, he could have at least faked being a good, respectful, attentive partner for a few years.

It’s also unclear how much he event wanted to come to America. It sounds like he’s all but being dragged to New Jersey by Ari.

What’s not just speculation is the effect that Bini’s breakup with Bria has had upon Ariela and her behavior during the relationship.

While Ari has many issues (so many), she has gone above and beyond what anyone could reasonably ask — all to reassure Bini that she’s not like his ex.

From moving to Ethiopia to giving birth there to showing an inordinate amount of patience, even to attending his religious ceremonies and festivals, 

Viewers have never heard from Bria, and one has to wonder if she would tell a very different version of events if she appeared on a Tell All.

Instead, we’re left guessing and hearing only Biniyam’s side of things.

It’s enough to make you wish that Ariela’s parents were messy enough to hire a P.I. to look into things.

Ariela Weinberg Gets Wine in the Face Over Biniyam Shibre’s Secret on 90 Day Fiance (Recap)

90 Day Fiance Season 9, Episode 3 continued several stories while bringing on one of the franchise’s most polarizing couples.

Ariela and Biniyam have Bini’s paperwork and his K-1 visa, but he hasn’t told his family.

Telling them at the last minute makes things worse — especially for Ariela, who somehow ends up getting the blame (and a face full of wine).

Bilal’s twisted test for Shaeeda, showing her a fake house and deducting points when she notices that something is wrong, has thus far earned her a D-.

Without knowing that she’s being tested, can she still get her grade up enough to see his real house?

Emily and Kobe are looking forward to spending time together, but Kobe is eager to meet his son for the first time.

Jibri brings Miona home to meet his parents, but they just can’t see eye-to-eye on when to make the move from Rapid City.

Yvette meets Mohamed at the airport, but despite their reunion being uneventful, things just feel … odd.

1. Ariela Weinberg and Biniyam Shibre

Ariela weinberg and biniyam shibre back now with documentation
One of The Other Way’s most talked-about, most polarizing couples is now ready to make their way to the United States via the K-1 visa. Biniyam now has his passport … after Ariela handled all of the paperwork to get it. They, and baby Avi, are just days away from making this journey and leaving Ethiopia behind.

2. But Biniyam hasn’t told anyone yet

Biniyam shibre i didnt tell them still now
The K-1 process takes a long time, and Bini had many opportunities to tell his friends and family. Instead, fearful of how they will respond when they find out that he is moving away, he has postponed telling them until now. (Presumably, they assume that he and Ariela are filming again for another season of The Other Way)

3. Most of us are familiar with Ari and Bini’s story

Biniyam shibre im married american woman ex wife recap
But for those who don’t (not everyone who watches the flagship series watches all of the spinoffs — there are so, so many), Biniyam explains how he was married once before to a different American woman whom he impregnated. Unlike with Ariela, he did not get to witness that baby’s birth. And now it has been several years since he last saw his firstborn son in person.

4. He and Ariela have their own son, Avi

Biniyam shibre recalls saying goodbye to ariela weinberg baby av
Avi was born in Ethiopia — Ariela flew there to give birth so that Bini could be there. However, Avi had a hernia and required surgery, so towards the end of their more recent season, Ari flew back with Avi to New Jersey for the hernia surgery. While she was gone, Biniyam’s existing behaviors — partying with friends, being unreachable for lengths of time — became even worse.

5. C’mon, man

Biniyam shibre i switched off my phone
Biniyam admits to the camera that while his fiancee and son were overseas, he would go out to clubs with friends, hang out with his buddies, and often turn his phone off or put it into airplane mode, making himself unreachable. He had these behaviors before, but then he was always (eventually) coming home to Ari. Instead, Bini was home alone, turning the house into a dance studio. While he insists that the women he invited over were just friends and that he did not cheat … things got pretty bad. For a guy who talks so much about being afraid of losing his family again, he didn’t really seem to make much of an effort to be a good partner for a long time. That changed when Biniyam met Ariela halfway, temporarily moving to Kenya to be with her and Avi and patch things up.

6. Fans generally like Ariela’s family

Janice weinberg chats ahead of k 1 trip neighbors family support
Her mother, Janice, has been part of their story since the first day. We see her chatting with Ariela, wondering how Bini will adapt to being neighbors with Ariela’s family. Ari’s parents are renting an apartment that isn’t too far from their home so that their daughter and future son-in-law and their grandson can be close at hand, which is a wonderful gesture. Ari admits that Bini has asked her to not tell her parents about their disagreements, because he wants them to have a good impression of him.

View Slideshow

Caroline Schwitzky Attempted Murder: What the Police Report Says About 90 Day Fiance Alum’s Attack

On Sunday, April 24, a 90 Day Fiance alum narrowly avoided an attempted murder. Her boyfriend of one year was arrested.

Caroline Schwitzky appeared on multiple episodes of 90 Day Fiance: Happily Ever After? during Russ and Paola Mayfield’s storyline.

Eyewitnesses described seeing Cole Goldberg restrain Caroline, pursuing her when she dove off of the boat to swim for safety, and nearly drown her.

Now, with a closer look at the police report, we can furnish further details of this harrowing ordeal.

Caroline Schwitzky on HEA 07 of 09

Starcasm got a direct look at documents put together by authorities after Caroline Schwitzky was attacked in front of witnesses.

It all went down on a boat on Lake Boca during an event called “Boca Bash.”

Eyewitnesses saw Caroline struggle to get away from him, dive and swim for safety, only for him to pursue and allegedly choke and attempt to drown her.

Caroline Schwitzky goes live in 2020

“[Cole] became more aggressive and [Caroline] began punching his arms to get him to let go,” one witness described to the Florida Fish and Wildlife officer.

After catching up with her in the water, “the man grabbed her by the throat with both hands attempting to strangle her.”

“And,” the summary of the eyewitness account continues, “was holding her under the water in a complete rage.”

Caroline Schwitzky on HEA 05 of 09

Two people jumped into the water from another boat, swimming to intervene.

They managed to get Caroline away from Cole, bringing her back onto their boat.

“We called 911 as he was hanging on to our boat,” one witness described.

Caroline Schwitzky on HEA 06 of 09

The officer noted: “Caroline had bruises on her leg and arm.”

The report continued: “Goldberg had bruises on both his knees and scratches.”

The officer added: “Goldberg was placed under arrest and transported to the Palm Beach County Jail.”

Caroline Schwitzky speaks about 2019 arrest

Cole was of course charged with felony attempted murder and with misdemeanor battery.

He was booked in the wee hours of Monday morning.

He managed to place $60,000 for release on bond within less than a day, and has an upcoming court hearing on May 26.

Cole Goldberg Mugshot

More of the report included even further witness details.

“We were yelling to him but he seemed unresponsive and kept holding her under,” one witness told the officer of the attempted drowning.

“My husband and sister in law jumped in to pull her up,” the witness shared, “and we tried to keep him away from our boat.”

Caroline Schwitzky on HEA 08 of 09

“His friends also witnessed this and would not let him back on the boat, they then drove away and let him in the water,” the witness detailed.

Another witnessed shared further details.

Caroline had actually asked for a flotation device from a nearby boat before being approached from behind for the nearly fatal attack.

Caroline Schwitzky on HEA 09 of 09

“Then a young man came up from behind her and grabbed her by the neck and pushed her underwater he held her under water,” the witness recalled.

“And [REDACTED] pulled her away from him,” the report continued. “I grabbed the boat hook and told him I would strike him with the pole.”

The report went on: “She got onto the boat and his friends picked him up then … minutes later he tried to swim to get on our boat, we called the police.”

Memphis Smith Confirms Split from Hamza: I’m a Single Mom!

The 90 Day Fiance: Before The 90 Days Season 5 Tell All filmed in January of this year.

At that time, Memphis and Hamza were still together.

A lot can change over the course of several months.

After weeks of intense rumors, Memphis has confirmed her split from Hamza — identifying herself as a “single mom” yet again.

Memphis Smith smiles during breastfeeding video

Memphis Smith, who registered to vote last year under the name Memphis Chardell-Arden Mokni, posted a new video.

In the Instagram post, Memphis is pumping breast milk.

It is neither feasible nor fair to expect a baby to be fed directly every time; breast milk can be pumped, stored, and then bottle-fed to babies.

Memphis Smith pumps milk

Memphis, a working mom, is wearing a positive attitude during the video.

It is so important to normalize breastfeeding.

Some past generations were so uptight about breastfeeding that they demanded that nursing mothers hide themselves while feeding their babies. Society is thankfully moving forward.

Memphis Smith breastfeeding video still

“LET’S TALK ABOUT IT!!” Memphis captioned her fun-spirited video.

“Ladies share your tips with one another! Open Forum!” she wrote, cautioning commenters: “NO NEGATIVITY or you will be BLOCKED”

Memphis added: “Breastfeeding/breast pumping mamas!! It doesn’t STOP because we work, it doesn’t STOP so we can sleep and it definitely doesn’t STOP so we can play!”

Memphis Smith IG with "single mom" caption

Memphis’ tags, however, were what really grabbed people’s attention.

“#breastfeeding #breastfeedingmom #breastfeedingjourney #breastfeedingworkingmom #pumpingmom #breastpumping,” she tagged.

Memphis continued: “#allmoms #newmomlife #singlemomlife #healthyhabits #breastfeedingawareness #postpartum.”

Hamza joins Memphis on the Tell All stage

Note the fourth-to-last tag, “singlemomlife.”

At first, we wondered if she had simply been making frequent use of this tag on her posts.

Instead, we found that while tags like “#postpartum” appeared on numerous Instagram captions, her references to being a “single mom” seem to be new.

Moknii Hamza proposes to Memphis Sandoval

It’s still possible that Memphis is speaking “to” single moms and not “as” a single mom.

But in conjunction with everything else that has come out about her and Hamza lately, that seems unlikely.

It might fly if production gives her an angry call about her NDA, but common sense says that she and Hamza are done.

Memphis Sandoval and Hamza embrace happily

A couple of months ago, Memphis suddenly purged every pic of Hamza from her Instagram.

Sometimes, it’s an NDA thing, but usually — especially when viewers know that a couple is together — it’s a better indicator of a breakup.

Even worse, Memphis and Hamza unfollowed each other. That’s never a good sign for a marriage.

Memphis Smith warns Hamza that if they don't marry this trip, it's over

On March 13, Memphis dropped another major hint that she and Hamza were through.

“Never love a man so much that you ignore the truth about him,” read a quote that she shared.

That seemed a little too on-the-nose to be a general piece of wisdom.

Memphis Smith suggests maybe they shouldn't be together

Hamza recently shared that he was hanging out in Chicago — not exactly Memphis’ native Michigan.

He also did not appear to be wearing a wedding ring, which further stirred up suspicions that things are really, truly over.

We don’t know what it’s all about, though leaked DMs between Memphis and Hamza’s sister Rawia suggest that jealousy over Memphis’ ex may be a factor.

Ariela Weinberg Gets Wine Thrown in Her Face in 90 Day Fiance Sneak Peek

More like Ariela WINEberg!

(I’m so sorry; I’ll see myself out)

After weeks of fans wondering when we’ll see Ariela and Biniyam on 90 Day Fiance Season 9, the wait is over.

If you want to see Bini’s sister throw wine in Ari’s face, you don’t even have to wait until Sunday.

In this sneak peek clip ahead of Season 9, Episode 3, this season’s one familiar couple — Ariela Weinberg and Biniyam Shibre — is back.

Bini is breaking the news to his family, specifically to sisters Mimi and Wish, that he’s moving from Ethiopia to New Jersey.

Ari is from New Jersey, her family lives there, and after so many mishaps (and the Tigray War in Ethiopia), that’s where they’re taking their family.

Mimi and Wish do not take the news well. Shocker.

“If you thought about us as a family, maybe a heads up would have been nice!” Wish admonishes Ariela in this sneak peek.

She laments: “Both you and her knew all this time and kept it secret. It sucks.”

Suck though it may, holding it back was Biniyam’s call, not Ariela’s, even though she is getting most of the blame.

“Him not telling you guys has nothing to do with me. It’s nothing to do with me at all!” Ari protests.

She emphasizes: “I would never tell him never not to tell his family, that would be so f–ked up on so many levels. I would never do that.”

“I don’t care whose fault it is, but if you think you are family, you should tell us,” Wish counters.

“He should tell us too,” Wish admits, before claiming: “We treat you like a sister.”

Wait, since when?

“You don’t treat me like a sister!” Ari fires back. “If that’s how you treat your sister, I want nothing to do with it.”

She tells them plainly: “I’m happy that I’m not going to see you guys anymore. And you know what? I’m not going to marry you guys. I’m marrying Biniyam.” 

This is when Wish douses her with a face full of red wine, leaving Ariela sputtering and admitting that the wine stings. Youch!

In case you needed a refresher, Ariela Weinberg is from New Jersey, Biniyam Shibre is from Ethiopia.

Before filming for the show, Ariela took an extended vacation in Ethiopia, where she met Bini and was overtaken by thirst.

That chance meeting led to a series of life-changing events, including appearing on Seasons 2 and 3 of 90 Day Fiance: The Other Way.

Biniyam and Ariela hooked up, and she ended up pregnant — but this was not really a “first” for either of them.

Ari has been married before, to a man from Argentina, though they are now divorced.

Biniyam was also married to an American woman before. Like Ari, she also had his child.

At every step of the way, Ariela bent over backwards to prove to Bini, his family, and herself that she is not like his ex.

Biniyam had missed the birth of his first child, unable to obtain a visa to the United States.

With that in mind, Ariela flew to Ethiopia, leaving her family and home behind, so that she could give birth in Ethiopa where Bini could be part of it.

At first, Biniyam made a good impression on viewers, even when his attempts to provide accommodations fell short.

He came across as a well-intentioned nice guy who would do anything for the mother of his child.

It was Ariela who ended up handling their housing needs. Once things were set up, her mom, Janice, flew home, planning to return for her grandbaby’s birth.

At the beginning of their first season, red flags seemed to be small in number.

Was it odd that Biniyam had now impregnated two different American women from affluent families? Yeah.

Was it encouraging that Ariela was admittedly “jealous” at heart? Not especially. But those aren’t huge deals compared to this franchise’s other drama.

Ariela got bad news, however, during a pre-natal checkup.

She had to deliver her son through an emergency C-section, which would have been scary even if her family had been there.

Instead, since she had to go to surgery with little warning, her family wouldn’t be there for some time.

Despite some initial concerns about baby Aviel, both he and Ariela were born healthy.

The couple’s next big worry turned out to be something that they should have discussed much earlier.

Biniyam wanted to circumcise his son. Ariela countered, highlighting her son’s human rights and worrying that he might grow up to hate her if she subjected him to genital mutilation.

This was a turning point for some viewers, because from one episode to the next, Ariela caved to family pressure from both sides.

Biniyam’s family had cultural expectations. Ariela is Jewish, and her father’s side of the family is also Jewish, and they had their own expectations.

Seeing Ariela do a 180, listening to her son’s screams in the hospital, lost her some fans who couldn’t understand her change of heart.

The main problems of their relationship were iterations of the same thing: Ariela would stay at home with Avi, Bini would leave for hours or days at a time.

Whether doing his “music” or hanging out with friends, he would sometimes turn off his phone or put it in airplane mode to stop her from being able to reach him.

Biniyam would defend this behavior by citing cultural norms, but it’s difficult to argue that he was being a good partner — or a good dad — by vanishing like that.

As we saw in the sneak peek for Ariela and Biniyam’s debut on Season 9, she also clashes with his sisters. A lot.

No matter how far she goes or how many concessions she makes in Bini’s favor, it’s never enough.

For two people who claim to fear that Ari will leave Bini “just like his ex,” Mimi and Wish at times seemed eager to drive her away.

Ariela and Biniyam, divisive though they are among fans, are one of the most one-sided couples to appear on the franchise.

In addition to moving to Ethiopia, Ariela has repeatedly attended Biniyam’s Ethiopian Orthodox Christian religious events, from ceremonies to holidays.

Some viewers have expressed discomfort at seeing a Jewish woman wrapped up in so many of her partner’s Christian celebrations without even a hint that he might return the favor.

Ariela has been put on blast again and again by fans who say that she whines and complains a lot — which, to be fair, she absolutely does.

But what has all of that complaining gotten her? Biniyam seems to get his way every time, dismissing her wishes as “ridiculous.”

In fact, this move to the United States seems to be the first time that Bini has made a major concession. Maybe coming to America will change things … but only time will tell.

Ariela weinberg gets wine thrown in her face in 90 day fiance sn

Caroline Schwitzky: Why Was the TARGET of Attempted Murder Arrested?!

Early this week, the boyfriend of a 90 Day Fiance alum was arrested for attempted murder.

Eyewitnesses and rescuers told investigators that Cole Goldberg had grabbed, strangled, and attempted to drown Caroline Schwitzky.

Caroline, who appeared on 90 Day Fiance: Happily Ever After? as a talent agent for Paola Mayfield, likely would have died had bystanders not rushed into action.

Now it’s reported that Caroline was arrested just after her ex-boyfriend. Why?

Caroline Schwitzky mugshot

Starcasm reports that Palm Beach County records show that Caroline was booked just 50 minutes after Cole Goldberg.

There are a lot of problems with the American justice system, but “was nearly murdered in front of witnesses” is not usually a crime.

Witness statements to police had not described Caroline as doing anything except try to get away, so what landed her behind bars?

Caroline Schwitzky speaks about 2019 arrest

The charge, it turns out, was an out-of-county warrant, and it is only natural to assume that it is connected to a Miami-Dade County felony conviction.

Caroline is on probation stemming from a controversial traffic stop, and an alleged probation violation was filed on March 25.

Her conviction for resisting an officer with violence to his person is only 5 months old, but actually stems from an incident in February 2019.

Caroline Schwitzky goes live in 2020

Caroline has adamantly denied the officer’s version of events, and repeatedly called for witnesses to come forward if they saw what happened.

On the one hand, Caroline has a lengthy history of traffic stops and driving citations — though it doesn’t look like others led to charges this serious.

At the same time, we’re talking about the officer’s word against that of a woman who turned down generous plea offers because she wanted to prove her innocence.

Caroline Schwitzky on HEA 06 of 09

If you’re scratching your head and wondering where you’ve seen Caroline before, you’re like a lot of people this week.

She appeared on Happily Ever After? in 2016, but only as part of the storyline of Russ and Paola Mayfield.

Caroline is the CEO of a Miami talent agency, and the Mayfields moved to Miami in part after her encouragement so that Pao could find work.

Cole Goldberg Mugshot

As for what happened on Sunday, Cole Goldberg allegedly attempted to murder Caroline Schwitzky.

The two had been dating for about one year.

Multiple witnesses saw the two in an argument while on a boat.

Caroline Schwitzky on HEA 04 of 09

Caroline reportedly tried to get away from Cole after he grabbed her.

The two struggled, with Cole allegedly restraining her despite her protests.

Apparently this conflict went on for about twenty minutes before Caroline, striking Cole’s arms in desperation, managed to break free.

Caroline Schwitzky on HEA 05 of 09

A boat is not an ideal place to flee an alleged attacker, so Caroline did the only thing that she could.

Witnesses saw her jump into the water and swim desperately to a nearby boat for safety.

Unfortunately, Cole jumped in after her, eventually overtaking her — which is when the alleged assault continued.

Caroline Schwitzky on HEA 02 of 09

Cole allegedly tried to push Caroline under the water, holding her underwater so that she could not breathe.

On top of that, he reportedly had his hands around her throat.

No one has the right to attack or detain their partner against their will, but it is this alleged behavior that landed Cole with an attempted murder charge.

Caroline Schwitzky on HEA 07 of 09

Witnesses, who described all that they saw to investigators, did not simply watch as this happened.

Multiple onlookers screamed for Cole to stop, apparently to no avail.

Desperate to save the woman’s life, multiple people jumped from a nearby boat, swimming over to rescue Caroline.

Caroline Schwitzky on HEA 09 of 09

These heroic rescuers, who had simply been minding their business on their boats minutes earlier, reached Caroline in time.

They saved her life.

According to police reports, they then had to fend off Cole with a stick.

Caroline Schwitzky on HEA 01 of 09

Cole was arrested on a charge of attempted first-degree murder.

Observing bruising on Caroline’s arms and after conferring with eyewitnesses, authorities also charged Cole with battery.

The 23-year-old was booked and processed, but managed to post $60,000 bond and was released just hours later.

Caroline Schwitzky on HEA 08 of 09

Outstanding warrants are a complicated matter, and people sometimes find themselves arrested on warrants that they did not know existed.

It is a tragedy that Caroline, rather than being able to process what happened to her on Sunday by seeking immediate counseling, was instead arrested alongside her alleged would-be murderer.

Whatever the substance of her alleged parole violation, one has to wonder about a justice system where the victim of an attack ends up in police crosshairs.

90 Day Fiancé Alum Caroline Schwitzky Rescued By Witnesses After Boyfriend Allegedly Tried To Murder Her In Public!

[Warning: Potentially Triggering Content] Whoa! The offscreen drama of 90 Day Fiancé continues to be even more shocking! According to reports, Happily Ever After? alum Caroline Schwitzky’s 23-year-old boyfriend was arrested and charged with first-degree attempted murder after allegedly attempting to strangle and drown her following a heated argument in Florida. Jeez! Jail records show […]

Read More…

The post <i>90 Day Fiancé</i> Alum Caroline Schwitzky Rescued By Witnesses After Boyfriend Allegedly Tried To Murder Her In Public! appeared first on Perez Hilton.

90 Day Fiancé’s Anny & Robert Share Final Photos Of Son: ‘Half Of My Heart Left With You’

90 Day Fiancé‘s Anny Francisco and Robert Springs are going through the unimaginable. Nearly one week after revealing that their 7-month-old son Adriel passed away, the couple have continued to mourn their sudden loss, with Anny sharing some of the last pictures she has of him to Instagram. On Sunday, the 32-year-old first posted several […]

Read More…

The post <i>90 Day Fiancé</i>’s Anny & Robert Share Final Photos Of Son: ‘Half Of My Heart Left With You’ appeared first on Perez Hilton.

Anny Francisco Mourns Baby Adriel: Half of My Heart Went With You

Last week, Anny Francisco and Robert Springs revealed the loss of their 7-month-old son.

Baby Adriel passed away, apparently after a health condition that required surgery.

Though Anny and Robert have not shared many details about losing their son, they have shared their honest grief with the world.

Anny’s newest post expresses the depths of her sorrow as she mourns her baby.

Anny Francisco and baby Adriel TikTok still

Taking to her Instagram Stories, Anny Francisco shared a throwback photo of herself kissing baby Adriel Hassan Springs.

Holding him in her arms outside, she captioned the photo in Spanish.

Translated, her words mean: “Half of my heart went with you.”

Anny Francisco IG half of her heart left with Adriel

She and Robert are going through what is, to most people, unimaginable grief.

To those unlucky few who know what it’s like to mourn a life that you created after it had scarcely begun, the feelings that she is expressing are familiar.

For seven months, Anny and Robert loved and nurtured baby Adriel. Now, they have to cope with his loss.

Anny Francisco IG - RIP baby Adriel

When Anny first revealed that her son had died, she vaguely suggested that his heart may have been related.

Some fans took this to mean a poetic reference. Others wondered if it was a literal heart condition.

Later, Anny shared some of Adriel’s final photos, and the details shed further light upon this tragedy.

Anny Francisco IG last photo of Adriel before surgery, death

Adriel’s final pictures before he passed included photos from just before his surgery.

Very few seven-month-olds undergo surgery of any kind.

In fact, with some rare (usually cultural) exceptions, surgery is only performed upon babies when absolutely necessary to save their life or preserve their long-term health.

Some fans are concluding that Adriel had a congenital heart condition of some kind.

There are hereditary heart defects, there are mutations, and sometimes an organ is simply malformed without a clear explanation.

While it’s true that there are heart defects that can repair themselves over time, others require life-saving action.

condolences to Anny Francisco IG 01 of 04

Any surgery comes with risks, and every parent whose child is fighting for their life against an illness knows this.

We can only imagine the kind of agonizing that Anny and Robert did before bringing in Adriel for surgery.

Similarly, hindsight can be torment, so we hope against all odds that they are not second-guessing having made the best choices that they could for their son.

condolences to Anny Francisco IG 02 of 04

Sometimes, there are no-win scenarios where surgery brings risks but avoiding medical intervention brings certain tragedy.

There’s no easy choice, there.

Fans are sure that Anny and Robert did everything that they could. That’s all that anyone could ask.

condolences to Anny Francisco IG 04 of 04

Anny and Robert are also parents to 20-month-old Brenda.

That is a complicated age — some children are old enough to understand death and loss, but many are not.

Robert’s other children, including fan-favorite son Bryson, are all old enough to understand the gravity of this. They lost their baby sister.

Anny Francisco IG - baby Adriel Hassan name reveal

We are sure that Robert and Anny have said so little on social media because they are still processing all of this.

They are also likely focused upon healing themselves and their loved ones as they all go through this together, albeit in their own ways.

There is no easy answer to grief. Recovering from loss isn’t easy. Our hearts continue to go out to them and their entire family.

Ariela Weinberg and Biniyam Shibre: Cut from 90 Day Fiance Season 9?

Um … where are Ariela Weinberg and Biniyam Shibre?

That’s the question that a lot of 90 Day Fiance viewers are asking, because we’re a couple of episodes into Season 9 with no sign of them.

They’re part of the Season 9 cast unless something very strange — but not unprecedented — has happened.

So when are viewers finally going to see them?

Ariela and Biniyam aren’t fan-favorites, exactly, but they are one of the most discussed and polarizing couples on the franchise.

That notoriety and divisive audience reaction earned them two seasons of 90 Day Fiance: The Other Way before they made the move, in more ways than one.

Now they’re supposed to be on 90 Day Fiance Season 9, with the show hyping things up by showing their drama on the trailer.

Biniyam Shibre is here in New York (90 Day Fiance S09)

Some fans feel weirded out that the show dangled this can’t-miss couple in front of them on trailers, but has now spent two full episodes introducing only new cast members.

Don’t get us wrong, we already have plenty to talk about from Season 9, Episode 1 and Season 9, Episode 2.

But did Ari and Bini get scrubbed like Alina Kasha? If not, how long will viewers have to wait.

Biniyam Shibre is in a new world (90 Day Fiance S09)

At the end of the second episode, however, the preview for Season 9, Episode 3 teased Ariela and Biniyam’s return.

It looks like things are starting out in Ethiopia, at least in part.

That would explain Ari’s messy sit-down with Biniyam’s sisters … the one that ends badly.

Ariela Weinberg gets splashed (90 Day Fiance S09)

Some fans want all new couples, others struggle to care about new faces, and a shocking number of viewers fall in both categories.

It seems likely that the editing team had that in mind, bringing back these two but not inundating viewers with them at first.

It’s also possible that Ari and Bini have less drama and thus less screen time, but given their history … that seems unlikely.

Ariela Weinberg is a free-spirited woman from New Jersey.

Biniyam Shibre is an entertainer from Ethiopia.

Filled with wanderlust, Ariela took an affordable extended vacation in Ethiopia, where she met Bini.

Ariela spotted Biniyam

Biniyam impregnated Ariela, which sounds like one of those random events … but this isn’t really new territory for the two of them.

Ariela was married for years to man from Argentina, where she met and lived with him.

And Biniyam was previously married to an American woman after, you guessed it, impregnating her, too.

Biniyam and Ariela at the temporary hovel

The specter of Biniyam’s previous marriage ended up dictating the shape of his and Ariela’s love story.

Ariela’s parents are both in medicine — her father a doctor, her mother a nurse — and could have given birth near home.

Instead, she flew back to Ethiopia while very pregnant so that Bini could witness the birth of his child, which he did not get to do the first time around.

Biniyam presents the "kitchen"

There were issues from the start, but initially, Biniyam made a good impression on viewers.

He seemed like a sweetheart, trying to accommodate Ariela, even though he came up short in several instances.

Ariela ended up being the one to cover their housing, so that all of her needs and Bini’s could be met as her due date approached.

Ariela Weinberg is a jealous person

Early on, the red flags seemed very small.

Yes, it was weird that Bini had impregnated two different American women.

It also seemed less than ideal that Ariela openly described herself as a “jealous” person, as fans wondered what would come of this.

Ariela Weinberg will need a C-section -- now

Ariela’s family had planned to fly to Ethiopia to see their grandbaby born and to help Ariela recover after giving birth.

Things turned out very different.

Ari ended up delivering early via emergency C-section, a terrifying prospect even under the best of circumstances.

Ariela Weinberg goes under for C-section

Fortunately, Ariela and Avi ended up being healthy, despite some initial concerns similar to those about Biniyam’s first son (who now lives in the US with his mother).

Next, Ari and Bini clashed over circumcision, which is a cultural practice in Ethiopia but which Ari opposed on humanitarian grounds.

Ariela is Jewish, but (like numerous Jewish intactivists) highlighted her infant son’s human rights, and feared that cosmetic surgery on his genitals without his consent might cause him to grow up to hate her.

Ariela Weinberg caves, makes a circumcision appointment

Viewers were perplexed, to say the least, when the next episode showed Ariela cave to pressure from Bini and from her own relatives.

Even after explaining to the camera why she knew that it was wrong, Ariela brought her son to be circumcised, weeping while listening to his screams of pain.

To say that Ari lost a lot of fans with that move is an understatement. 

baby Aviel Biniyam Shibre

What followed of their life in Ethiopia was a lot of the same conflicts, playing out again and again and again.

Biniyam would essentially vanish for hours or even days at a time, leaving his girlfriend (and later, fiancee) wondering where he was.

He would ignore her calls or even put his phone in airplane mode to make himself unreachable, even knowing that his baby was at home.

Wish Shibre - if you don't baptize, the baby goes straight to hell

Ariela also got into conflict with Biniyam’s family, particularly with sisters Mimi and Wish.

Even attending family events and supporting Bini as he pursues his “music career,” it seems that she can do no right in their eyes.

And when Ariela reaches out to them to find out where Bini is when he disappears, they accuse her of being controlling.

Wish Shibre - finally, baby Avi is baptised

Even Ari’s toughest critics cannot honestly claim that she didn’t try — in fact, she bent over backwards to meet Bini’s family’s demands.

After moving to Ethiopia to not only give birth but begin to raise their son, Ariela also attended numerous religious rights to please Biniyam.

Numerous viewers have expressed discomfort at seeing a Jewish woman attend so many Orthodox Christian ceremonies and sacred sites, with zero reciprocation.

Ariela Weinberg uncomfortable after ice cold holy water shower

In fact, for all of Ariela’s whining and tears, it seems that Biniyam is the one who regularly gets his way.

A few times, Ari has put her foot down, like after Biniyam turned their house into party central and allegedly cheated on her.

At the end of their last season of The Other Way, the couple resolved to move to America … assuming that Bini’s K-1 visa could be approved.

Ariela Weinberg returns, no longer wants to talk to Bini's sisters

It’s no secret that it was approved. Even if we hadn’t reported on Bini being in the U.S. before, he also appeared in person on the Tell All.

Maybe they will have fewer conflicts now that Biniyam is away from bad influences and is less likely to vanish for days at a time.

Or maybe they’ll have brand new problems to overcome now that Bini, not Ari, is the fish out of water. We’ll find out soon.

90 Day Fiance Alum Nearly Dies; Boyfriend Arrested for Attempted Murder

These days, the relationship status between Russ and Paola Mayfield sounds pretty iffy.

But 90 Day Fiance viewers remember that there was a time when the only apparent obstacle to their marriage was Pao’s career.

Paola is a model. Russ had a lot of hang-ups about it.

One of the key figures in their story was nearly the victim of a homicide, and her ex-boyfriend has been arrested for attempted murder.

Caroline Schwitzky on HEA 06 of 09

In 2016, Caroline Schwitzky appeared on 90 Day Fiance: Happily Ever After?

She was not part of the main cast, but appeared as part of Russ and Paola Mayfield’s storyline.

Caroline is the CEO of a Miami talent agency, and it was partially through her encouragement that Pao moved to Miami for work.

Cole Goldberg Mugshot

TMZ reports that officers from the Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission say that Cole Goldberg attempted to murder Caroline Schiwtzky on Sunday, April 24.

Cole was Caroline’s boyfriend of one year.

Eyewitnesses in West Palm Beach described the two getting into a heated argument while on a boat.

Caroline Schwitzky on HEA 04 of 09

According to the report by law enforcement, witnesses saw Caroline try to get away from Cole.

Unfortunately, he allegedly held her despite her struggles, even aggressively grabbing her in order to keep her from leaving the boat.

Eyewitnesses saw this go on for about twenty minutes, the report says, with Caroline eventually breaking free only after punching Cole’s arms to loosen his grasp.

Caroline Schwitzky on HEA 05 of 09

Breaking free from Cole’s immediate hold was apparently not enough.

Seemingly in terror, Caroline fled from the boat, jumping into the water to swim for a nearby boat.

Reportedly, Cole jumped into the water in pursuit, eventually catching up to her in the water.

Caroline Schwitzky on HEA 02 of 09

This is where the report becomes even more upsetting.

Eyewitnesses told investigators that they saw Cole try to push Caroline under the water.

They described Cole grabbing Caroline by the throat with both hands, seemingly trying to strangle her while holding her beneath the water.

Caroline Schwitzky on HEA 07 of 09

Naturally, those of us reading this report wondered what onlookers were doing, but the report covers that, too.

Witnesses told authorities that they screamed at Cole to stop, but that he refused to listen and continued to attempt to drown and strangle Caroline.

Several people from a nearby boat jumped into the water to rescue her.

Caroline Schwitzky on HEA 09 of 09

The rescuers were able to pull Caroline away from Cole.

The report says that they then had to fend him off with a stick.

Had it not been for those nearby in other boats leaping to action, this horror could have ended even worse.

Caroline Schwitzky on HEA 01 of 09

Instead, officers arrested Cole for attempted first-degree murder.

He is also facing a battery charge, and investigators noted that there was bruising on Caroline’s arms.

23-year-old Cole was booked and processed in the wee hours of Monday morning, released just hours later after posting a $60,000 bond.

Caroline Schwitzky on HEA 08 of 09

We hope that Caroline is safe and recovering.

Physical injuries take time to heal. Trauma can take a years, decades, or a lifetime.

Whatever 90 Day Fiance viewers may have thought of her half a dozen years ago is moot — no one deserves this nightmare.

Anna-Marie Campisi and Mursel Mistanoglu Welcome Baby Boy via Surrogate

Early this year, Anna-Marie Campisi and Mursel Mistanoglu announced that they were expecting their first child.

They were having their first child together — Anna’s fourth overall — via surrogate.

At the time, they had no idea that their baby would be born in a war zone as a mad despot tries to annex Ukraine.

After crossing multiple borders, Mursel being hospitalized, and more, the fan-favorite couple welcomed their baby boy.

On Monday, April 25, the beloved beekeepers broke the news, with Anna writing a lengthy post on Instagram.

“Mursel and I are excited to announce the birth of our son!” she began.

“Gokhan John,” Anna wrote, confirming her son’s name. “He was born 4/11/22, 5 weeks early.”

Anna Campisi IG childbirth announcement

“He’s doing amazing!” Anna assured her fans and followers.

“Just a small guy at 5.3 pounds 18 inches,” she notes, describing a newborn within the normal range for length and barely below the normal range for weight.

“Our surrogate is also doing well!” Anna shared.

“I was able to meet her,” Anna-Marie detailed, “and she’s such an amazing woman!”

“We want to shout out to an amazing non-profit group, Dynamo Project,” she expressed.

“Upon arrival to Poland we spoke with the group to start logistics of our travel into Ukraine,” Anna wrote.

“They asked to see Mursel’s Schengen Visa to see if it was a one entry or multi entry visa,” Anna recalled.

“We found out it was a one time entry visa,” she confirmed.

“So from there,” Anna explained, “the plan was for Mursel to stay in Poland.”

“If he came with to Ukraine, he wouldn’t be allowed to leave,” Anna reasoned.

“So I had to go into Ukraine alone,” she added. Ukraine was and is a war zone.

With that in mind, Anna expressed: “Thank God for this amazing group Dynamo Project!”

Anna-Marie Campisi and Mursel Mistanoglu ultrasound pic

“I didn’t have to go alone,” Anna affirmed.

“They planned the logistics including travel into ukraine, a safe place to stay while in Ukraine, and travel while inside,” she praised.

Anna added: “They were with me the entire time.”

“We left Warsaw with Project Dynamo,” Anna narrated, “they crossed us across the border by foot and then transported us to a safer hotel.”

She continued: “The next day I was transported to pick up our baby and get all of the documents completed while inside Lviv, Ukraine.”

Then, things took a turn.

“On our way back to the hotel, they told me Mursel was transported to the hospital via ambulance, due to heart pain,” Anna revealed.

“A member of Project Dynamo stayed with him until I was able to meet him,” she shared, “so he wouldn’t be lost in the shuffle.”

Anna continued: “Then I was transported to the border and walked across into Poland with the baby.”

Anna and Mursel 90 Day Fiance S7 teaser 2

“They got me to the hospital where Mursel was,” Anna praised.

“The tests came back that his heart was ok,” she assured followers, “and bloodwork came back ok.”

“So,” Anna went on, “we went back to Warsaw after.”

Anna-Marie Campisi and Mursel Mistanoglu IG pregnancy announcement

“Dynamo Project helped with that also,” Anna noted. “This is such an amazing group!”

“They go into countries with wars and hostile environments to help people get out!” she praised.

“They have helped numerous people in Ukraine get out of towns,” Anna added. “They’ve moved surrogates and babies.”

Anna with Mursel  (90 Day Fiance S7)

“We will forever be grateful to them!” Anna declared.

Certainly, that is one of the most eventful childbirth stories that any of us are likely to read.

We’re glad that everyone involved is safe and well. We continue to be heartbroken for the people of Ukraine, but we are happy for Anna-Marie and Mursel!

Anny Francisco and Robert Springs Mourn Baby Adriel: How Did He Die?

Last week, 90 Day Fiance fan-favorites Anny Francisco and Robert Springs announced the tragic death of their 7-month-old son.

Countless fans expressed their sorrow, and castmates showered Anny and Robert with love and condolences in their time of grief.

Obviously, a lot of people had understandable questions, even while remaining sensitive to Anny and Robert.

Anny is shedding light upon the cause of death — and sharing the final photos of baby Adriel.

Anny Francisco and baby Adriel TikTok still

Adriel Hassan Springs was just 7 months old.

Anny has now revealed that he had gone into surgery prior to his passing, sharing his final photos with fans.

This is heartbreaking for us all, but most of all for Anny and Robert.

Anny Francisco IG last photo of Adriel before surgery, death

“These were the last photos before my son’s surgery,” Anny wrote in Spanish on Instagram.

“Life is unfair,” she attested.

Anny expressed: “I just wanted to have my children.”

As with the revelation that Adriel had passed away, there was an outpouring of messages of love, comfort, and sorrow.

Castmates like Larissa Lima and Armando Rubio wrote to Anny.

So, of course, have thousands of fans.

Anny Francisco IG - RIP baby Adriel

Anny did not reveal the cause of death for Adriel.

These topics are painful to discuss. Even when someone dies during surgery, the cause of death can be complicated.

However, she did hint at what may have taken place during her initial tragic announcement last week.

condolences to Anny Francisco IG 01 of 04

Last week, Anny wrote of Adriel that “he was a fighter.”

However, she offered in explanation that “his heart couldn’t take it.”

It is of course none of our business, but one has to grimly assume that Adriel had a heart defect and did not survive the surgery.

condolences to Anny Francisco IG 02 of 04

Many parents are familiar with the agonizing struggle of having a baby who needs surgery.

Infants can require major surgery at extremely young ages, some undergoing serious procedures even before leaving the hospital after being born.

It is a frightening prospect, but parents know that life-saving medical intervention is sometimes needed to save their child’s life.

condolences to Anny Francisco IG 03 of 04

In some cases, there is no happy ending and no “best option.”

We do not know what condition Adriel may have had, or what surgery he may have undergone — we can only guess.

But it is possible that he would have passed away last week with or without surgery. Again, we do not know.

What we know with certainty is that the entire family is now grieving this terrible loss.

Robert and Anny loved their baby boy, who was born last autumn.

And their daughter, Brenda Aaliyah Springs, was looking forward to being a big sister — and now has to learn about death at a very tender age.

Anny Francisco IG - baby Adriel Hassan name reveal

Rober is also a father of several children from previous relationships.

Viewers loved his son, Bryson, who was his youngest before he and Anny married and started having children.

He’s an adorable young boy, and we can only imagine how he is processing this.

Robert son Bryson 90 Day Fiance s7

Our hearts continue to go out to the entire family.

While Anny and Robert have the emotional support of loved ones along with countless fans, nothing can make this easy.

Grief is a natural process, but processing pain takes time, and nothing can take away from this tragic loss.

Bilal Hazziez Pranks Shaeeda Sween with Dilapidated House on 90 Day Fiance (Recap)

90 Day Fiance Season 9 continues with Episode 2.

Shaeeda arrives, beginning Bilal’s unhinged “test” involving driving a work van to his childhood home to see how his fiancee responds.

Emily nervously heads to pick up Kobe, but not before hearing a friend’s honest concerns and worrying if she’s being “selfish.”

Jibri brushes off the concerns of his friends and family and goes all out to prepare to welcome Miona.

Kara gets to see good friends in the DR before she and Guillermo fly home to the U.S. Once there, Guillermo is detained.

And we are introduced to a new new couple.

In contrast to Kara and Guillermo’s six year “age gap,” Yvette and Mohamed are more than two decades apart.

Yvette has a lot going on in her life, but her friends clearly have reservations about her 25-year-old fiance.

1. Bilal Hazziez and Shaeeda Sween

Bilal hazziez drives the van to the airport
Bilal has designed an elaborate “prank” for Shaeeda, following months of refusing to show her his home or his car and hiding his lifestyle from her. He’s picking her up in a well-used work van, not his Mercedes, and planning to take her to his childhood home, which is in need of repair in several ways, both inside and out. Some fans are praising this as genius, others as a bouquet of red flags for controlling and toxic behavior.

2. Pranks aside, the reunion is very sweet

Bilal hazziez reunites with shaeeda sween at aiport
We’ve seen couples with more PDA, but given Bilal and Shaeeda taking their shared faith very seriously, their embrace is certainly enough.

3. Shaeeda is eager to get to know Bilal

Shaeeda sween seeing his house seeing his car
She has asked to learn more about his life — and he has declined. While many of us would flatly refuse to go live somewhere without seeing the home first, Shaeeda loves him enough to make the trip to Kansas City, Missouri. She hopes to get some questions answered, too.

4. Oh no

Shaeeda sween scooby doo van babe
Shaeeda hilariously describes Bilal’s (fake) vehicle as a “Scooby-Doo van,” which is amazing. She thought that the somewhat more generic car (what was it, a Chevy? I don’t know anything about cars) beside it was his and did not imagine that this super sketchy van, loaded with stuff as if Bilal hadn’t even tried to tidy it up before she came.

5. As respectfully as possible …

Shaeeda sween but this is completely unacceptable
Shaeeda tells Bilal very calmly and directly that he is not meeting her expectations. She’s not comfortable even putting her luggage in the back the van, which was not cleaned or cleared out and appears to have some sort of work equipment.

6. It gets worse

Bilal hazziez takes her to the fake house
Many people would love to have a house that they own outright, even on in disrepair, but there’s a difference between suddenly coming into home ownership and doing what Shaeeda believes is happening — finding out that the man you love, who has hidden his lifestyle from you, is living in a home in desperate need of repair, some of which is visible from the street.

View Slideshow

Yvette "Yve" Arellano Deflowered Mohamed Abdelhamed: He Was a Virgin!

Yvette Arellano and Mohamed Abdelhamed did not appear in the Season 9 premiere of 90 Day Fiance.

They and two other couples will be introduced as the season continues — with Yve and Mohamed making their debut in Episode 2.

We can already see footage from their first appearance in a sneak peek clip.

Dining out with her friends, Yvette discusses her sex life — and reveals that Mohamed was a virgin before they met.

In this preview of Season 9, Episode 2, Yvette is channeling a blend of Real Housewives and Sex in the City while dining with friends.

“Okay, so in their culture, there’s no public display of affection,” her friend says of Mohamed, who is from Egypt.

The friend then asks: “Okay, so then, how long did you wait until you guys had sex?”

The 48-year-old visited 25-year-old Mohamed in Egypt when she visited him and his family.

“You can’t like, stay together,” Yve explained.

“But, you know, you can stay in the same hotel…let’s just say that,” she dished to her friends.

“He was a virgin, wasn’t he?” another friend asks, clearly already knowing the answer.

There is a momentary pause before Yvette quietly answers: “Yes.”

Whether that’s true or she’s just saying that for Mohamed’s benefit is anyone’s guess, as we’ll explain momentarily.

Yve’s friends then have a lot of questions about their sex life.

It is very unusual for a woman in her forties to have sex with someone who has not had sex before, and things that were cute when one’s in high school can be red flags when you’re a grownup.

So they ask if he knows to hit key erogenous zones, like her clitoris and nipples, making Yvette blush awkwardly.

 

Without getting too specific, Yve adamantely affirms that Mohamed is a “rockstar” when it comes to sex.

“Let’s just say the sex life is just fine,” she reassured her friends.

Despite understanding that her friends are asking for the camera’s benefit, Yvette adds: “Multiple times a day, okay? Fine.”

Yvette spoke to the confessional camera to explain why she and Mohamed had put their relationship over certain cultural demands.

“In the Muslim religion, they don’t believe in premarital sex or relations,” she acknowledged.

Some other religions have similar restrictions, though because all religious adherents are humans, there are people of all faiths who do or do not make exceptions.

“But we were just basically so convinced that this is the one,” Yve tells the camera.

“So I think that that’s why we went against things,” she reasons, “even though it was breaking rules.”

Yvette also admits that discussing all of this with her friends on camera made her “very uncomfortable,” though her friend group is never one to hold back.

“I know it’s something that in his religion, they don’t talk about that much,” Yve acknowledged.

“So, I just wanted to be more reserved about that,” she explained, “out of respect for him.”

Doubtless, production asked her friend group to ask personal questions as they would even if the cameras weren’t rolling.

Yvette yve arellano deflowered mohamed abdelhamed he was a virgi

90 Day Fiance Scandal: Is Miona Bell Blackfishing?

Just watching the Season 9 premiere of 90 Day Fiance, Miona and Jibri Bell seemed … fine?

Obvious conflicts over their wedding and where to live seemed inevitable, but hardly insurmountable.

But fans have spied major 90 Day Fiance red flags, and one of them is Miona.

Jibri’s Serbian lady love appears in a wide variety of skin tones on social media … and is getting accused of blackfishing.

Miona and Jibri Bell met in Serbia. They are now going through the visa process to bring her to the United States.

Between disagreements over how long they should live in South Dakota with his parents to wedding plans, they have a lot of hurdles ahead.

All in all, their premiere episode only raised a handful of red flags — that’s pretty good, considering the drama that this show can feature.

Miona Bell - I'm a little bit nervous too, definitely

But years before she met Jibri, Miona looked very different than she does now.

Her social media history goes back for years, as you will see in examples below.

In 2015, she had the sort of fair skin that you would expect from a Serbian woman. In contrast …

tweet asking if Miona Bell is blackfishing

… In many of Miona’s recent photos, she is sporting golden brown skin of varying levels of darkness.

Now, sometimes, people simply tan. Makeup that darkens skin is not tanning.

And when darkened skin is combined with certain hairstyles, styling choices, and ways of presenting yourself online, it often means blackfishing.

Blackfishing definition via urbandictionary

Blackfishing is a complicated topic, but it is a play on the word “catfishing” and particularly common among influencers.

Essentially, someone who is not Black will style themselves to either appear Black or ethnically ambiguous, as if wearing Blackness as a costume — or a product.

The idea can be to broaden ones consumer base or seek clout without actually claiming to be Black, and it is a pernicious and racist practice.

tweet of Miona Bell skin tone array (blackfishing)

As concerned viewers on Twitter have noted, Miona has undergone some major changes in her appearance over the years.

It’s of course true that some of this could be explained with natural tanning — everyone has the right to tan, even if it’s not necessarily a healthy choice.

But combined with the makeup choices, how she wears her hair, and more, it seems more like wearing Blackness as a costume. Is that what’s happening here?

Miona Bell IG response to blackfishing accusations

Miona did not wait for the Tell All to respond to questions (and perhaps some outright attacks), taking to Instagram in response.

She notes that she is Serbian, but reports that she has Mexican and Middle Eastern heritage as well.

That is not an ideal defense, if it is even one at all, especially since vague ancestry from dubious DNA reports means very little in terms of how race is viewed within society.

Jibri Bell met Miona in Serbia

First of all, someone of Mexican or Middle Eastern descent could also perpetuate anti-Black racism by, among other things, Blackfishing.

Second of all, while heritage is worthy of celebration, race is something inherited from one’s immediate ancestors — like parents.

Of course it’s a complicated topic (race is an ill-defined social construct) but it is not unreasonable to ask if a reality star is participating in a toxic, exploitative trend.

90 Day Fiance Season 9 promo with Miona and Jibri

No one person can give a white person — or any other person of color — “permission” to cosplay as a Black person for social media clout.

That said, in the most practical sense, the most important opinions about Miona’s chameleon-like changing of skin tone are of Jibri and his family.

It sounds like Jibri is fine with things, considering that he liked Miona’s post (and also married her). But how will his mother react?

Miona gives Jibri an ultimatum (90 Day Fiance S09)

We don’t know if it will come up this season, especially given the franchise’s track record.

Cast members with racism scandals are not treated equally. Lisa Hamme was quietly fired. Alina Kasha was loudly fired. Mike Berk’s racist scandal was ignored by the show.

It would be nice to see Season 9’s Tell All special tackle this topic head on, because it matters — and maybe, as Miona suggests, there’s something that we’re not seeing.