The Hottest Bachelor Stars in History: Where Does Matt James Rank??

With Matt James about to make history on ABC, it’s almost time again to talk about The Bachelor spoilers … but also this:

Which Bachelor is the #1 hottest of all time!?

‘Cause, you know, even if ABC does scour the Earth for eligible dudes who are the total package, that’s still a real debate.

And subjective, we know. But a fun one!

For those keeping score, Matt is the star of The Bachelor‘s 25th season on ABC, making him the 24th Bachelor of all time.

(Brad Womack famously got two cracks at the main event … and yet didn’t get a happily ever, or even close, after either).

Obviously, Matt is the first black Bachelor, and the second black lead in the franchise overall, after Rachel Lindsay.

The show’s low-key racism and how it needs to handle Matt’s season in 2021 are subjects that will be debated at length.

But we’re glad he’s the new leading man of the franchise, and today we’re just here for pointless fun in honor of James.

Take a look at the ghosts of Bachelors past and see for yourself who’s the hottest of the hot and where you’d rank Matt.

24. Matt Grant

Matt grant photograph
Matt Grant is, if you couldn’t immediately tell, British. He’s the first (and only) British Bachelor, in fact. Amazingly, he gave his final rose to none other than Shayne Lamas. They were engaged for like 45 minutes before she upgraded BIGLY to celebrity gossip blogging legend, scholar and entrepreneur Nik Richie.

23. Lorenzo Borghese

Lorenzo borghese photo
If there were a Bachelor, and season of The Bachelor, that left less than a memorable impression, it might have to be Lorenzo Borghese. He is eminently forgettable. But he’s not exactly hard to look upon.

22. Andrew Firestone

Andrew firestone pic
Is Andrew Firestone a contender for Hottest Bachelor Ever? Maybe. Do you remember that he was actually on The Bachelor? Less-convincing maybe.

21. Bob Guiney

Bob guiney carves a turkey
Bachelor Bob Guiney starred in Season 4 of the ABC hit. No, seriously, he did. Guy was kind of a turkey TBH.

20. Charlie O’Connell

Charlie oconnell
Not to be confused with his brother Jerry O’Connell, who’s starred on things like Sliders, Scream 2, and Crossing Jordan, Charlie O’Connell once starred on the ABC show.

19. Byron Velvick

Byron velvick
The bass-fishing Byron Velvick had the outdoorsy thing going for him in Season 7, that’s for sure. He got engaged to Mary Delgado, with whom he had a tumultuous relationship.

View Slideshow

Matt James: Just Who is the New Bachelor?!?

History has been made, ladies and gentlemen.

Following an outpouring of criticism and pressure directed at ABC, producers at last made the decision in June 2020 to cast an African-American as the lead of The Bachelor.

Are you ready for your close-up, Matt James?!?

With viewers buzzing over this selection and with the Black Lives Matter movement reveling in this (admittedly very small) victory, it’s time to get to know Matt James.

Just who the Season 25 star?

Find out below!

1. It’s Official!

Matt james as the bachelor
“We know we have a responsibility to make sure the love stories we’re seeing onscreen are representative of the world we live in, and we are proudly in service to our audience,” a statement by ABC read upon making this announcement. “This is just the beginning, and we will continue to take action with regard to diversity issues on this franchise. We feel so privileged to have Matt as our first Black Bachelor and we cannot wait to embark on this journey with him.”

2. Protests Really Do Work

Bachelor request
In the days leading up to this casting, thousands of viewers and also a bunch of Bachelor Nation alums signed a petition and urged ABC to finally cast a person of color in this role.

3. So.. Who IS Matt James?

Matt james in nyc
He was originally cast as a suitor on Clare Crawley’s upcoming season of The Bachelorette. He made headlines back in April 2020 after Crawley seemingly called him out for being on the show for the “wrong reasons,” only to fire back that he’s only active on the Cameo app in order to raise money for coronavirus relief.

4. He’s Best Friends with Tyler Cameron

Matt james and tyler cameron
James even spent a chunk of his COVID-19 quarantine alongside Cameron in Florida, where he also hung out a lot with Hannah Brown.

5. How Did He Meet Cameron?

Matt james and tyler cameron
These two hunks met while attending Wake Forest University and moved in together in New York City in October of 2019.

6. The Guy Can Dance!

Hannah brown and tyler cameron tiktok dancing
We present this TikTok — with Tyler and then Hannah! – as evidence.

View Slideshow